Roll up Your Sleeves
The winner of the 2012-13 award was goaltender Rob Madore, who took home individual award in five of his six games played since making his home debut on March 26. That continued a trend of goaltenders doing well in the competition, with teammate Mike Murphy taking home the inaugural award in 2011-12 by winning the nightly honor eight times.
Full results and standings appear below.
| Season Standings | ||
| Player | Points | Game(s) Nominated |
| Rob Madore | 25 | March 26 vs. Norfolk, March 30 vs. San Antonio, April 6 vs. Milwaukee, April 11 vs. Texas, April 12 vs. Texas |
| Justin Peters | 20 | Nov. 4 vs. Chicago, Dec. 15 vs. Houston, Feb. 10 vs. San Antonio, March 3 vs. Oklahoma City |
| Nicolas Blanchard | 15 | Dec. 10 vs. Milwaukee, March 13 vs. Norfolk, March 29 vs. San Antonio |
| Dan Ellis | 15 | Nov. 6 vs. Chicago, Dec. 7 vs. Lake Erie, Dec. 14 vs. Houston |
| Jerome Samson | 15 | Dec. 1 vs. Rockford, Dec. 6 vs. Lake Erie, Dec. 21 vs. Peoria |
| Matt Marquardt | 10 | March 9 vs. Houston, March 10 vs. Houston |
| Luke Pither | 10 | Jan. 16 vs. Grand Rapids, Jan. 20 vs. Norfolk |
| Brett Sutter | 10 | Dec. 2 vs. Rockford, April 7 vs. Milwaukee |
| Chris Terry | 10 | Nov. 10 vs. Peoria, Jan. 25 vs. Abbotsford |
| Drayson Bowman | 5 | Nov. 8 vs. Peoria |
| Zach Boychuk | 5 | Nov. 24 vs. Oklahoma City |
| Michal Jordan | 5 | Jan. 17 vs. Grand Rapids |
| David Marshall | 5 | March 17 vs. Texas |
| John Muse | 5 | Jan. 26 vs. Abbotsford |
| Rasmus Rissanen | 5 | Nov. 25 vs. Oklahoma City |
| Bobby Sanguinetti | 5 | Dec. 20 vs. Peoria |
| Beau Schmitz | 5 | March 15 vs. Texas |
| Jared Staal | 5 | Feb. 9 vs. San Antonio |
| Tim Wallace | 5 | Dec. 11 vs. Milwaukee |
